-
Website
http://capitolfax.com/ -
Original page
http://capitolfax.com/2007/12/05/question-of-the-day-seat-belts/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
wordslinger
96 comments · 42 points
-
Rich Miller
147 comments · 56 points
-
LoopLady
16 comments · 6 points
-
theoriginallynns
16 comments · 2 points
-
dupage dan
28 comments · 2 points
-
-
Popular Threads
I know a couple people that do not wear a belt because it is "uncomfortable." If that is not the definition of short-sighted, I do not know what is.
The only time I don't wear a seatbelt is typically when I'm taking a taxi cab in Chicago. Now that I think about that, it's not smart and I should start doing so. I'm suddenly getting images of Tarantino's "Death Proof."
Glad to hear you're OK.
I actually don't know anybody personally who refuses to wear them, thankfully.
Make sure you use them in the back seat, too.
Glad you are ok Rich.
B) Always wear the belt. My wife is a medical professional so when we come accross an acident that the police haven't responded to we stop to see if there are injuries (she is sort of required to).
Anyway we came upon an acident on 55 just south of the I-55 / I-80 intersection. Car took the exit ramp too fast and went off the road. We get to the car and one other person had stoped at that point. We id the victom including one person we thought was a pile of clothes on the side of the road (got tossed out of the car wasn't wearing her belt if I recall). I stayed with the victom in the back seat checking him and keeping him awake while my wife and the paramedic helped the woman who got ejected.
I read later she died.
The image of her there motionless, with my wife, the paramedic and another person who was in the car doing CPR will stick with me the rest of my life.
Also my wife has turned my kids into complete belt cops...
I am fighting with my oldest now who seems to think its not "cool" to clip in. I'll email her this *^^*
When the law was first passed and not a primary offense it ticked me off - big brother and nanny state, etc. Then they made it a primary offense (reneged on their promise not to) with a fine of $75, and being a very cheap Scotsman, I have worn it ever since. It really is no bother now, just a habit done without much thought. However, it's stories like yours and a couple of posters that remind me of how much sense it really makes and the potential and sometimes real cost of my stubbornness.
You're absolutely right about people who don't wear their belts. The most I ever do is not wear my belt when driving a couple of blocks to the dry cleaner or CVS. But if the weather's bad, even that is reckless.
I know some people hate when big nanny government comes in and tells them what to do, but my response is get over it and stop being an idiot.
I don't know why, I just never put the belt on, even in the front seat (which is rare, and cab front seats are always covered in junk). I should be more careful to put on the seatbelt.
I also try to remind passengers to put theirs on when I'm driving. It's odd to me when people always put their seat belts on when they are driving, but then don't when they are passengers.
I know a couple of people like that. I don't get it. At least in a cab, you have the bullet proof glass to keep you from being ejected (though I'm sure it would hurt like hell to be thrown into that)
Should be: Wear it to keep from having an accident-you can't control the car if you're sliding all over the seat or using the steering wheel as a brace.
Fighter pilots and race car drivers always wear them for that reason, not because they may crash.
I always wear mine when operating equipment-makes me a better operator.
VanillaMen do not risk their lives for fashion or frivolity. They do what is needed to protect their families from harm while traveling. This requires the wearing of seat belts at all times.
Obviously Rich, you do the right thing. Good man!
If I were a motorcycle rider, I'd wear a star-spangled, red, white and blue helmet because I have worked in a hospital and have seen the results of motorcycle accidents.
I remember a statistic from driver's education in high school where they told us that a majority of accidents occur within 2 miles of your home. You tend to let your guard down in familiar environments and that's when accidents occur. Something to keep in mind.
My Chevy truck has that "ding-ding" and the dashboard lights up if the passenger has not buckled up. Gives me a convenient way to tell them to buckle up so the darn thing will not keep dinging. I really want them to buckle up and be safe, but this way I'm not specifically preaching at them unless I am feeling in the mood to preach.
I *always* wear my belt, and have since I was a kid in the late 1960s. My Grandfather pounded it into me.
I've actually worn out belts in a few cars and have had to replace them!
That said, the post above seems to be par for the course in Illinois. What a mindset!!!
People "having the right to do what they want."
How Crazy!!
As a big city dweller, I implore cab passengers to use their seatbelts. Being slammed into the plastic driver's safety shield almost cost a friend his right eye. Just look at the bolts in one of those shields the next time you're in a Chicago cab, think of the impact with your face and you'll join all of us who use seatbelts automatically. Now ... if only Amtrak and school buses had seatbelts ...
Girth is a factor! When I was 125 lb heavier (hey it's been a good year for my health!) I seldom wore my seatbelt especially in my partner's Camaro because it didn't fit.
I simply got into the habit to where it is automatic.
No way would I be that stupid. lol. That car stays in the garage if there's even a hint of snow in the forecast.
A good friend of mine was traveling to an interview (I think it was on I-90) and she was in the right lane. A semi in the center lane suddenly moved into her lane, cut her off and she swerved to avoid the truck, hit some gravel on the shoulder, spun the car and ended up flipping it three or four times along the grassy side of the road.
Thankfully, she was wearing her belt. The car was upside down, but she was able to undo her belt and crawl out the back window. She walked away from the wreck with some minor bumps and bruises. The car (Saturn) was a total loss.
EVERYONE who is in the car, when I am driving, needs to be buckled. Doesn't matter if it's a short trip, hot day, I'm sleeping, older car (I drove a '66 Mustang) whatever. I honestly don't feel right without it. Now if I could get my dogs to wear one, that would be great --- but I at least have their leashes connected to the parking brake so they won't fly out of the car.
Only time I don't is in a cab downtown --- but if it's any farther than a mile, I dig around and find the belt. And that's probably the time I need it the most!
I'm glad you're ok Rich! It's terrifying when something like that happens --- and when you come upon an accident where someone HASN'T worn one, you realize just how much they're needed.
I wear mine 99.9% of the time, and as a side note wear (And believe EVERYONE should wear one) a helmet when I ride a Motorcycle.
Glad you are ok Rich.
I wasn't hurt other than a small scrape on my hand where a piece of safety glass scratched me as I climbed out the space where the windshield had been. There's a very awkward moment after you have flipped a car and next you end up upside down sitting there listening to the radio. Of course, at that age, I was pretty much thinking I'd never drive again until I was 30.
It has also saved me in a wreck where a driver hit me--it kept me in control and behind the wheel instead of in the on-coming lane of traffic.
I always wear my seat belt. And I find the mandate far more important than just for my health. Seat belts turn major accidents into minor ones by keeping drivers behind the wheel and in control of their vehicle. It's not just an issue of personal safety, it is a basic traffic safety measure.
Even if upside down. ;)
Glad to hear you were okay, and I am betting I know the curve it happened on.
your personal life in this instance to convince
others to do the right thing.....wear the freakin'
seat belt, people. i refuse to start driving
unless everyone is belted in. glad you are not
too bruised. warm bath, jack daniels, keep safe everyone.
Glad Rich is good.
That's why I've bought two. I will take a large repair bill if it means I'm in a car that will save my life. The safety features are amazing and frankly, it responds so well that it makes avoiding accidents easier.
To the point -- I go to the extreme. I always were a seatbelt. I require that anyone else in the car wear a seatbelt. When I ride cabs (usually twice a day) I wear a seat belt. I don't trust the driving of most cab drivers, so I always have it on.
That being said -- let me also say that I have problems with the seat belt law. The only person harmed in an accident in which the person didn't use seatbelts is the user. People should have the freedom to do stupid stuff if they will be the only victim.
I also have issues with the fact that on most cars -- including the BMW -- it is very difficult to turn the air bag off (which can be a big problem when the passenger is very small), but that's another matter completely.
I see your point.
Mine were both 3 Series sedans (the first had RWD and stick, the current has AWD and automatic).
If I had the Z I would park it in winter too.
The old RWD was a great car on snow and ice. The new one is very good.
I am not sure what goes through peoples minds when driving in conditions that are dangerous. Not wearing seat belts, not turning on their lights, trying to keep up with traffic that is going too fast for conditions. Don't be afraid to be the dork driving in the right lane letting all the big shots fly by. I can't tell you how many times I have seen the cool guys in the ditch a few miles ahead.
Spinning uncontrollably on ice in a vehicle may be one of the most discomforting sensation you can experience. I did the exact same thing on a state route about ten years ago ... I think I might have hit the only patch of ice in Illinois, but my vehicle spun all the way around at least twice before the back end smashed into an permanent road sign just off the road. As I was getting out, a semi going the other direction flew by, and I still feel fortunate I hadn't been in that spot a few seconds later.
Not wearing one's seat belt is one of the dumbest decisions anyone could make. It's a totally unnecessary risk to take ... little different than playing Russian Roulette.
My family and I always wear our belts.
I began wearing my religiously after my little brother hit a windrow of snow on the side of the road and launched my 1970 Dodge Dart over a ditch and fence-line, landed it on the roof and walked away despite his failure to buckle up -- side note: he was 12. I figure he used up every ounce of our family's collective luck in that accident and that I should build-up my own seat-belt karma pool.
My father in law does not buckle up because he has a very large waistline. If someone figured out a way to make seat-belts more comfortable -- perhaps a sleeve that makes the belt wider and bite less -- there is a fortune to be made.
-- SCAM
PS. Glad everyone was okay.
I have been wearing seat belts religiously since 1968. At that time I just wanted to avoid sliding around the seat when cornering.
I do not put the car in gear until all passengers are belted. I've had wise guys take off their belts when I am flying, but a short steep dive gets their attention.
I do however dislike the mandatory seat belt laws. Especially the primary stop for seat belt violation. (I do support mandatory restraints for children) It is not uniformly enforced.
Most police officers, will not issue seat belt violations after an accident because they believe that people are punished enough. Silly reasoning.
I kind of like the system in Germany where your medical coverage is limited if you are not wearing seat belts and are injured in an accident.
I always wear seat belts and feel 'naked' if it is not around me. My daughter has always worn hers, too! there's never been a discussion about it since she stopped using a car seat. It is a great habit to have whether it is law or not. And, by the way, I use turn signals, too, as second nature...wish more would, but then I am a mutant who likes the old way about MANY things!
My driver demanded that I not wear my seat belt, even though the roads were a collection of treacherous hairpin switchback curves, filled with potholes and populated with really awful drivers.
The reason: A seatbelt was a dead giveaway that I was a foreigner. Since we were heading into the heart of rebel bandit country, we would be prime targets.
Considering that neither of my friends (one dead, one hospitalized) was wearing a belt when they were forced off a mountain road by bandits, I thought this was the goofiest idea ever. Not to mention that I in no way resemble the typical Albanian of that region - we'd be targets no matter what.
But he insisted and I complied.
That was not a fun excursion.
I always wear my seatbelt regardless of destination. I was involved in a crash on US 67 near Monmouth a few years back. Long story short, the ISP trooper told me that, had I not been belted in, he would have been picking me out of the windshield. Pretty much sealed the deal for me and anyone else in my car.
A friend of mine was thrown into the backseat of her car during an accident once, and walked away with just bruises and cuts. The front end of the car was so smashed in, the steering wheel was deeply embedded into the driver's side seat. The police officer even told her at that time she was lucky she hadn't been wearing her seatbelt, because the steering wheel would have severed her in half and she would have most likely died.
For myself, I am only 5 foot 1 inch tall. The strap cuts straight across my throat. My cousin (who is the same height as me) had her throat gashed open because of this during an accident once. Being that I suffer from PTSD due to an incident where someone tried to slit my throat open, I cannot wear a seat belt that is sitting on my throat without panicking.
I would rather pay my $25 fine (that's what it is in Sangamon County if you show up the date of court hearing) than drive panicky and take the risk of being trapped inside of the car during a fire or other incident.
Scariest experience I ever had was when I was in high school. My buddy drove us to school. He owned a Ford Bronco II. It was snowing out, and the conditions were icy. We were on our way to school, and were taking side streets because the main roads were jammed with traffic. We were doing no more than 20 miles/hour when we hit an icy patch.
The truck spun three times before we even knew it, and we ended up facing the opposite direction.
Anyone that's been in a Bronco II knows that it feels like it will tip even going in a straight line. We thought we were going to tip the truck that day, but it didn't, thank God.
It seems to me that seat belts should be available to everyone, regardless of size. That law says everyone is required to wear one.
Seatbelts save lives...everyone should have access to them.
The auto-makers should be required to make seatbelts available for every size passenger.
Check out the current seatbelt regulations and think of how many people you know who are outside of these measurements.
http://www.ifisher.com/cfr.asp
More info regarding this issue:
http://www.ifisher.com/disagree.asp
http://www.ifisher.com/signthepetition.asp
The above isn't my website, but I want people to be aware of this issue.
Rich - I'm glad you're okay.
And I will start wearing my seatbelt all the time.
God Bless!
Glad you came out of it alright and we should all keep the AFSCME guy in the other car in our prayers.
The land of the free is less and less that everyday!
Kiyoshi - the reason most accidents occur within 2 miles of your home is because that is where you do the most driving. Law of averages, according to my friendly neighborhood police officer.
Wear it everywhere.
Though I do hate that I am required by law to wear it. If I want to be dumb, why can't I? You can ride around on a motorcycle with no seat belt or helmet, but I get a ticket if mine isn't on? wtF?
my mom was always paranoid about wearing one when I was a kid. She was convinced that if we got in an accident her seat belt would malfunction and trap her in a burning car. But then again my mom is wacked out from doing drugs in the 60's and 70's. Thanks to that attitude about seat belts is really why I never got into wearing them.
So glad to know you're both ok!
I always wear my seatbelt and make sure my passengers do too. My high school driver's ed. teacher who also happened to be the athletic director, Mr. Bernard, was paralyzed when he was involved in a car accident with the high school's football coach. Neither had their seatbelt on. The football coach was killed and Mr. Bernard didn't have a scratch on his body, but became paralyed when the van flipped and he hit his head on the roof of the van. Imagine not getting a scratch on you and KNOWING that had your seatbelt been on, you could've walked away from the accident the way you did. He shared that story with all of his students so that we'd learn from his mistake. Anyway, he was a living example to me for why I should ALWAYS wear my seatbelt.
As for people who think it should be a matter of choice, that's fine as long as you agree that your medical treatment stops as soon as your insurance runs out. No public money for you!
In college I was a passenger in a car that was involved in a minor fender bender on the Poplar Street Bridge after a STL Cardinals ballgame. I was wearing my seat belt but realized that even low speed accidents could cause you some real harm. I've never hesitated to wear my seatbelt since that day.
It's become all the more important as we've taught our 5 year the importance of buckling up. Although he is going through a seatbelt nazi phase as he points out everyone not wearing their belt.
I hope you will heal quick Rich...please wear your seatbelt, we need you and the info you provide...
Always wear it. Like Montrose said, once we had a kid it became very apparent how important it is to to everything you can to stick around as long as possible... even if it means wrinkling my clothes (there's a reader under the dome who knows I'm talking to him).
There are plenty of things that distract drivers, not just this enemy of the moment.
Children, I've found, can be a huge distraction in the car. Want to ban them?
[this question may have been asked, but am too lazy to read through all of the comments.]
Moot? Are you serious?
I wasn't talking on the phone, eating, drinking anything or even listening to the radio when I had my accident. I wasn't on any medication, I was fully rested and felt pretty alert. My hands were in the 10-2 position and I was sitting upright and looking intently at the road.
But by your logic, I didn't need to wear a seatbelt because I wasn't distracted. That's kinda weird.
And it proves my point how some "evil of the moment" pumped up by elements in the media can cause people to lose their common sense and empathy.
My boyfriend will drive off without his belt on and half way down the road, or mid-turn he'll put it on. Drives me crazy when he does that.
But at least now she'll have to stop teasing me about my wreck, so I've got that going for me.
Habbit I guess.
Glad you are OK and you got to spend some time with Kenny.
That was the best part of the experience. We had a good ol' time.
My late father-in-law (deceased, but not in a car accident) would unfasten his seat belt when we turned onto his street after a trip. I'd recite, in a nasal voice, the admonition that you hear on airplanes: "Please remain seated with your seatbelt fastened until the aircraft has come to a complete stop at the gate." I guess I was really irritating, but it worked.
Interestingly, ISP didn't make them standard until the '63s.
BUCKLE UP.
Keep the message moving.... Buckle up .... Seatbelts save lives!
That's what was going through my mind as we were sliding on our side. lol
Plus the car makes an annoying beeping sound if I don't fasten.
Rich, bring on some more Albanian stories. That little snippet was facinating.
Almost never use my seatbelt. Have acquiesced to my daughters's insistance that I wear one on the Interstate. Chalk it up to a combination of:
1) Habit, didn't have to use one when I started.
2) Personal Freedom, my RIGHT to chose (same as smoker's argument).
3) Big Brother, The State has its nose in enough of my business.
Personally, I'm glad my daughters took Driver's Ed., and were 'indoctrinated' into buckling up, without giving it a thought.
And I probably should know better. The first summer of driving, I 'cart-wheeled' my step-dad's car. Fortunately, it was just after a heavy rain, and the ground was soggy enough to cushion the effect. But I still remember, feeling like being in a clothes dryer.
AA's parents were both extraordinarily good drivers who needed a lot of coaxing to get into a seatbelt in their later years, but once it took, they never stopped. I've always had a fast car and never roll unbelted.
With the kids,I borrowed the approach my older brother, a (retired) Naval Aviator used with his kids. He essentially taught a simple auto equivalent of the "before-start checklist" pilots of Beeches to Boeings use before they turn 'er over. About 4-5 steps, with step 4 Fasten Seatbelt and Step 5 turn the key. Like any other rote or drill, if they learn it from the git-go, it sticks with them.
My daughter took the front end off her car two month after she got her license; the car's impact-absorbing design took most of the impact, with the seatbelts taking the rest. No airbag deployment. She and her passenger were uninjured. Had they been unbelted, the airbags would have deployed at full speed, with good bruises at a minimum, and a good possibility of broken bones or airbag burns.
Her first boyfriend rolled his car late last year on a rural road. He was not wearing a seatbelt, was ejected from the car and was killed instantly.
Moot that, Anon.
A bit off-topic, but relevant to the season-I don't think a number of automakers are doing their customers any favors with the wheel/tire combinations that are getting fitted to more and more cars/SUVs. With Rich's Z3 and my little er, Volkswagen, we knew when we bought those cars that they came with "summer tires" that would be useless in snow or on ice. On the other hand, I see Buicks with 19" summer tires, 'Slades with 22's (I like bling as much as the next guy, but that setup could flip on dry ground) and Nissan rentals with biiig wide 18's..sitting in the median of I-55. Seat belts, Air bags, Traction Control, ABS, ESP...none of it is any good if you have no grip. I just looked at an AWD German Sedan with every safety gadget known to man and a set of tires made for a racetrack. Caveat emptor.
I think he was either being stubborn, thought he was indestructible (he did survive the Battle of the Bulge and several other incidents that could have killed him) or maybe he had some crazy idea that safety precautions weren't "manly." He's 84 years old and in a nursing home now, so his driving days are probably over. My mom has always said, only partly in jest, that his guardian angel worked overtime :)
so happy to hear you and your wife are OK. We're on our way back from a road trip to CA with the family so I have a renewed appreciation for how crazy interstate driving can be! Seatbelts are a must.
Personally I don't think its the right of the government to regulate whether someone wears a seat belt. I usually wear a seat belt out of habit while I'm driving. However, when I'm a passenger I don't always put one on.
Thanks for the advice but I think I'll stick with my '31 Essex Coupe - more my speed!
I am glad to hear you are OK, and I don't want to nag, but after having to send three snowplows out during the new year day's blizzard a few years back to try and reach a stranded family of four because they were going 'shopping' in Bloomington - I have to ask "what are you people thinking?"
Sorry Rich, this topic touches a nerve.
Use Public Transportation
or
Just Stay Home.
The emergency workers and hospital staff in the towns along I-55, I-57, I-80, I-72 etc will thank you.
But it is unfortunate that more of the safety features in open wheel race cars are not incorporated into passenger cars. Seeing Kubica hit the wall head on in Canada and walk away with a minor headache, or seeing any of Dario Franchitti's flips this year (he had at least two and teammate Marco Andretti went over a few times also) and both didn't even miss a race tells you that real safety is a possibility.
Also, at risk of getting too far off the subject -- between BMW's I owned a Mercedes C230. NOT recommended for snow or ice. If you are going German, stick to the Ultimate Driving Machine.
My dad--despite referring to helmet-less motorcyclists as "organ donors"--used to go without a seatbelt regularly. He finds it uncomfortable. Now, he'll buckle up to stop the nagging of the "ding ding ding" in his truck. (I gave up the harassment after high school, so he has only the dashboard to glare at now.)
I get nervous if there's not a belt for me to use (e.g., in taxis and buses). A bunch of my friends were in an incredibly scary accident many years ago after a blowout on the Poplar St. Bridge (to StL). Those who'd been in the backseat and weren't buckled in--well, they didn't stay in the backseat long. They did, however, stay in the hospital for a long and frightening time.
Again--really glad you're OK.